HomePractice areas
18-wheeler accidentsAuto accidentsMotorcycle accidentsDrunk driving accidentsTrain accidentsConstruction accidentsRefinery and oil rig accidentsWorkplace injuriesHead and brain injuriesSpinal cord injuriesBurn injuriesWrongful death
ResultsAttorneysHow we workAreas we serveArticlesFAQContact Español Call 713-520-7701

Your case and the law

Texas Comparative Negligence: The 51 Percent Rule

By Hampton & RawlingsUpdated November 20, 20266 min read

Short answer

Texas uses a modified comparative fault system called proportionate responsibility. The jury assigns each party a percentage of responsibility. If you are more than 50 percent responsible, you recover nothing. If you are 50 percent or less, your damages are reduced by your percentage (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 33.001, 33.012). That is why people call it the 51 percent bar rule.

Key takeaways

  • Texas bars recovery only when the injured person is more than 50 percent responsible (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.001).
  • At 50 percent or less, damages are reduced by the injured person's own percentage (§ 33.012(a)).
  • Juries can assign fault to settling persons and designated responsible third parties, not just the parties at trial (§ 33.003).
  • A defendant found more than 50 percent responsible is jointly and severally liable for the recoverable damages (§ 33.013(b)).
  • Seat-belt nonuse and similar conduct can reduce recovery only with evidence that it caused or worsened the injuries (Nabors Well Services v. Romero, Tex. 2015).

What is the 51 percent rule in Texas?

Texas law says a claimant "may not recover damages if his percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent" (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.001). A claimant is the person seeking damages. So:

  • At 50 percent or less, you can still recover, but the court reduces your damages by a percentage equal to your own share (§ 33.012(a)).
  • At 51 percent or more, you recover nothing.

An example in percentages: if a jury finds you 20 percent responsible, the court cuts your damages by 20 percent. If it finds you 51 percent responsible, the claim fails.

The Supreme Court of Texas applied this rule in JCW Electronics, Inc. v. Garza, 257 S.W.3d 701 (Tex. 2008). The jury found the man who died 60 percent responsible for his own death. Because his share was over 50 percent, the court rendered judgment that his family take nothing. In a death case, the person who died is treated as a claimant, so his or her share of fault counts (§ 33.011(1)).

Is Texas a contributory negligence state?

Before comparative fault, Texas followed contributory negligence. As the Supreme Court of Texas explained in Dugger v. Arredondo, 408 S.W.3d 825 (Tex. 2013), under that system a plaintiff who was even one percent at fault could not recover. The Legislature adopted a comparative negligence statute in 1973, and the scheme was later replaced by the proportionate responsibility rules now in Chapter 33.

In Dugger, the court held that Chapter 33 displaced the old "unlawful acts" defense, which had barred recovery by a plaintiff who was breaking the law when hurt. The court said the statute shows "the Legislature's desire to compare responsibility for injuries rather than bar recovery, even if the claimant was partly at fault or violated some legal standard." A plaintiff's conduct reduces recovery, but it does not completely bar recovery unless the plaintiff is more than 50 percent responsible or a narrow statutory defense applies. One such defense covers a plaintiff who was committing a felony, later finally convicted, that was the sole cause of the plaintiff's damages (§ 93.001).

Who gets a percentage of fault?

For each claim, the trier of fact (usually the jury) must assign a percentage of responsibility, in whole numbers, to each of these (§ 33.003(a)):

  • each claimant;
  • each defendant;
  • each settling person, meaning anyone who paid or promised to pay the claimant to resolve potential liability (§ 33.011(5)); and
  • each responsible third party designated under § 33.004.

The percentages cover conduct that caused or contributed to cause the harm "in any way," whether by negligence, a defective product, or other conduct that violates a legal standard. The jury may not be asked about anyone's conduct without sufficient evidence to support the question (§ 33.003(b)).

Chapter 33 applies to tort claims (claims for civil wrongs such as negligence) and to Deceptive Trade Practices Act claims (§ 33.002(a)). The Supreme Court of Texas has applied it to dram shop claims against bars and stores (F.F.P. Operating Partners, L.P. v. Dueñez, 237 S.W.3d 680 (Tex. 2007)). See our guide to Texas dram shop law.

Can my seat belt or safety choices count against me?

They can, if the defense proves they made your injuries worse. In Nabors Well Services, Ltd. v. Romero, 456 S.W.3d 553 (Tex. 2015), the Supreme Court of Texas overruled its old ban on seat-belt evidence. It held that relevant evidence of seat-belt use or nonuse, and relevant evidence of a plaintiff's "pre-occurrence, injury-causing conduct generally," is admissible to apportion responsibility, "provided that the plaintiff's conduct caused or was a cause of his damages."

The court set limits. The defendant can show relevance only with evidence that nonuse caused or contributed to the injuries. The trial judge should decide relevance outside the jury's presence. Expert testimony will often be needed. A plaintiff's failure to mitigate damages after the occurrence is handled separately: it reduces the damages award and is not part of the percentage split. The same questions come up for motorcycle riders; see our post on the Texas motorcycle helmet law.

What is a responsible third party in Texas?

A responsible third party is a person alleged to have caused or contributed to the harm, whether or not that person is a party to the lawsuit (§ 33.011(6)). Defendants use this to put another name on the verdict form. The main rules (§ 33.004):

  • The defendant must file a motion for leave to designate the person on or before the 60th day before trial, unless the court finds good cause to allow a later filing.
  • The court must grant the motion unless another party objects within 15 days after service and shows the defendant did not plead sufficient facts, even after a chance to replead.
  • A defendant may not designate someone after limitations has run against that person if the defendant failed to make required timely disclosures.
  • After adequate time for discovery, a party may move to strike the designation. The court must grant it unless the defendant produces enough evidence to raise a genuine fact issue about the person's responsibility.
  • A designation, or a finding of fault against the person, does not by itself make that person liable.

The Supreme Court of Texas walked through these steps in In re Eagleridge Operating, LLC, 642 S.W.3d 518 (Tex. 2022). It left in place a trial court order striking a designation because the designated company's legal responsibility for the premises defect ended when it conveyed its ownership interest. Designations matter because, as the next section explains, a defendant is usually liable only for its own percentage.

When does joint and several liability apply in Texas?

Usually, each liable defendant pays only the percentage of damages equal to its own percentage of responsibility (§ 33.013(a)). A defendant becomes jointly and severally liable, meaning responsible for the full recoverable damages, if its percentage is greater than 50 percent, or if it acted with specific intent to do harm, in concert with another person, in committing certain listed crimes (§ 33.013(b)). A defendant who pays more than its share can seek contribution from other liable defendants (§ 33.015).

An example in percentages: a jury finds a trucking company 60 percent responsible, another driver 30 percent, and you 10 percent. Your damages are reduced by 10 percent. The trucking company, at more than 50 percent, is jointly and severally liable for that reduced amount. The other driver is liable only for its 30 percent share. For more on trucking cases, see who is liable in a Texas truck accident.

Settlements matter too. If you settle with some parties, the court further reduces your recovery by the total dollar amount of all settlements (§ 33.012(b)), with a different option in health care liability cases (§ 33.012(c)).

What this means after a Houston crash

A few percentage points can decide whether you recover anything. That makes evidence about how the crash happened important: photos, witness names, vehicle damage, and the Texas crash report (CR-3). Be careful about casual statements to an insurance adjuster about what you could have done differently.

Most Texas personal injury suits must be filed within two years after the claim accrues (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003). Exceptions exist, so talk to a lawyer about your facts.

Getting help with a disputed-fault case

If an insurer is blaming you for a crash in Harris County or nearby, Hampton & Rawlings offers a free case review. Learn about our car accident practice or contact us.

Questions we hear

Can I recover if I was 50 percent at fault in Texas?

Yes. Recovery is barred only if your percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. At exactly 50 percent, your damages are reduced by half (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 33.001, 33.012(a)).

Is Texas a pure comparative negligence state?

No. Texas uses a modified system: an injured person who is more than 50 percent responsible recovers nothing (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.001).

Who decides the percentages of fault?

The trier of fact, usually the jury, assigns percentages in whole numbers to each claimant, defendant, settling person, and designated responsible third party (§ 33.003(a)).

Does breaking a traffic law automatically bar my claim?

No. In Dugger v. Arredondo (Tex. 2013), the Supreme Court of Texas held that a plaintiff's illegal conduct is apportioned under Chapter 33 rather than barring recovery, unless a statutory defense such as § 93.001 applies.

Sources

Every legal statement in this article is based on these primary sources.

  1. statuteTex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 33.001-.00451 percent bar, applicability, percentage findings, and responsible third party designation.
  2. statuteTex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §§ 33.011-.015Definitions, reduction of damages, settlement credits, joint and several liability over 50 percent, and contribution.
  3. statuteTex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 93.001Affirmative defense when the plaintiff was committing a felony, later finally convicted, that was the sole cause of the damages.
  4. statuteTex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003Two-year limitations period for personal injury suits.
  5. caseJCW Electronics, Inc. v. Garza, 257 S.W.3d 701 (Tex. 2008)Chapter 33 applied; a decedent found 60 percent responsible barred recovery and the court rendered a take-nothing judgment.
  6. caseDugger v. Arredondo, 408 S.W.3d 825 (Tex. 2013)Chapter 33 abrogated the common law unlawful acts doctrine; a plaintiff's illegal conduct is apportioned rather than a complete bar.
  7. caseNabors Well Services, Ltd. v. Romero, 456 S.W.3d 553 (Tex. 2015)Relevant evidence of seat-belt nonuse and other pre-occurrence, injury-causing conduct is admissible to apportion responsibility if it caused the damages.
  8. caseIn re Eagleridge Operating, LLC, 642 S.W.3d 518 (Tex. 2022)Describes the responsible third party designation and strike procedure; denied mandamus from an order striking a designation.
  9. caseF.F.P. Operating Partners, L.P. v. Dueñez, 237 S.W.3d 680 (Tex. 2007)Chapter 33 proportionate responsibility applies to Dram Shop Act claims.

General information, not legal advice. This article explains Texas law in general terms as of November 20, 2026. Laws change, and every case depends on its facts. Talk to a lawyer about your situation. The information on this website is general information, not legal advice. Reading it, or contacting Hampton & Rawlings through it, does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send confidential information until we have agreed to represent you.

Keep reading

More on your case and the law

Free case review

Questions about your case?

713-520-7701

5020 Montrose Blvd., Suite 700, Houston, Texas 77006. Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Hablamos español. No fee unless you are paid. If there is no recovery, the firm pays the case expenses.

What happened?

Confidential. A lawyer reviews every request. Please do not include sensitive details until we talk.

Call 713-520-7701